Why do you think it is important to protect industrial design? Justify your answer with the help of relevant provisions under the Design Act, 2000.
QUESTION 4 —
Why do you think it is important to protect industrial design? Justify your answer with the help of relevant provisions under the Design Act, 2000.
1. Meaning of Industrial Design
An industrial design refers to the aesthetic or visual features of an article.
These may include:
- Shape
- Configuration
- Pattern
- Ornamentation
- Composition of lines or colors
- Any aesthetic appearance applied to an article
Statutory Definition (Section 2(d), Designs Act, 2000)
A design is the features of shape, configuration, pattern, ornament or composition applied to any article by any industrial process, which in its finished state appeals to and is judged solely by the eye.
2. Importance of Protecting Industrial Designs
Protection of industrial design is essential for creativity, economic growth, competition, and consumer protection.
The following points justify its importance:
(a) Encourages Creativity and Innovation
Design protection rewards creators for their original and aesthetic innovations.
It motivates industries and designers to create new, unique and attractive product designs.
(b) Prevents Imitation and Copying
Once registered, others cannot copy or imitate the design.
This prevents:
- unfair competition
- market confusion
- loss of originality
(c) Provides Exclusive Rights to Designer (Section 11)
A registered design grants the owner exclusive right to apply the design to the article for 10 years (renewable for 5 more years).
This creates a monopoly for a limited period.
(d) Promotes Economic Development
Attractive designs increase the commercial value of products and help companies gain market share.
Examples: mobile phone shapes, luxury goods, bottles, furniture, etc.
(e) Enhances Market Competition
Companies compete to create visually appealing designs, leading to:
- better quality products
- more choices for consumers
- improved industry standards
(f) Consumer Attraction and Brand Identity
Consumers often choose products based on their appearance.
A registered design helps build:
- brand identity
- customer trust
- product recognition
(g) Supports Industrial and Manufacturing Growth
Design rights encourage small and large manufacturers to invest in new technologies and processes.
(h) Helps in International Trade
Design protection supports global trade by preventing counterfeit products from entering the market.
India’s Designs Act aligns with TRIPS Agreement.
3. Relevant Provisions Under the Designs Act, 2000
(a) Section 4 — Prohibition of Registration of Certain Designs
Ensures only new and original designs are granted protection.
(b) Section 11 — Duration of Protection
- 10 years from registration
- Extendable for 5 more years
Shows the law gives a limited monopoly to protect investment.
(c) Section 22 — Piracy of Registered Design
Defines infringement (piracy) and provides remedies such as:
- injunction
- damages
- seizure of infringing products
(d) Section 19 — Cancellation of Registration
If design is not new or has been published earlier, it can be cancelled.
Ensures quality and originality.
(e) Section 10 — Register of Designs
Encourages transparency and public access to registered designs.
4. Remedies for Infringement (Section 22)
If someone copies a registered design, the owner can claim:
- Damages up to ₹50,000 per design
- Injunction against further use
- Delivery of infringing articles
- Civil suit for piracy
These remedies show that the law strongly protects industrial designs.
5. Important Case Laws Related to Industrial Design
(1) Bharat Glass Tube Ltd. v. Gopal Glass Works Ltd. (2008, Supreme Court)
Facts:
Issue regarding originality of a glass sheet design.
Held:
- The design was new and original.
- The appearance created by shape and pattern constituted a valid design.
Importance:
Defines newness, originality, and visual appeal under Section 2(d).
Useful for meaning and importance of design protection.
(2) Mohan Lal v. Sona Paint and Hardware (Delhi HC)
Held:
- Explained difference between a trademark and design.
- A design becomes a trademark only after acquiring secondary meaning.
Importance:
Shows why design protection is necessary before the product becomes a brand.
(3) Reckitt Benckiser v. Wyeth (Delhi HC)
Facts:
Dispute over design of a medicine bottle.
Held:
- Functional features are not protected.
- Only aesthetic appearance is protected.
Importance:
Helps in explaining scope and limits of design protection.
(4) Rotomac Pens v. Milap Marketing (1999)
Facts:
Copying of pen designs.
Held:
Copying the shape and look of a pen constitutes design infringement.
Importance:
Shows how design protection prevents imitation in everyday consumer goods.
(5) Cello Household v. Modware (2017)
Facts:
Imitation of water bottle shapes and patterns.
Held:
Court granted injunction against the infringer.
Importance:
Demonstrates the commercial importance of design registration.
6. Conclusion
Industrial design protection is crucial because it encourages creativity, prevents unfair competition, strengthens brand identity, promotes economic development, and benefits consumers.
The Designs Act, 2000 ensures these objectives through provisions on registration, exclusive rights, piracy prevention and legal remedies.
Case laws further clarify how courts protect visual originality and penalize imitation.
.
Comments
Post a Comment