Income from Other Sources (Sections 56–58) – Detailed Analysis

: Income from Other Sources (Sections 56–58) – Detailed Analysis

Under the Income Tax Act, 1961, there are five main heads of income — salary, house property, business or profession, capital gains, and income from other sources. The fifth head, “Income from Other Sources,” acts as a residual head. This means that if any income cannot be taxed under the other four heads, it will be taxed under this head. The purpose of these sections is to ensure that no income escapes taxation just because it doesn’t belong to a specific category.

---

Section 56 – Charging Section

Section 56(1) is the main charging section. It says that any income which is not chargeable to tax under any other head will be taxed under the head “Income from Other Sources.” In simple terms, it means all leftover or miscellaneous incomes are included here.

Some common examples include dividends, lottery winnings, interest income, rent from sub-letting, gifts received without consideration, and family pension. Even advance money forfeited from sale of a property comes under this head if the sale does not take place.

Section 56(2) also specifies certain incomes that are always taxable under this head, such as:

• Money or property received as a gift without consideration (if value exceeds ₹50,000).
• Share premium received by closely held companies in excess of fair market value.
• Compensation received on termination of employment.

---

Important Case Laws under Section 56

1. CIT v. D.P. Sandu Bros. Chembur (P) Ltd. (2005, SC)
   In this case, the assessee received compensation for surrendering tenancy rights. The Court held that since tenancy rights are a capital asset, the amount cannot be taxed again under “Other Sources.”
   ➤ Principle: The same income cannot be taxed twice — under capital gains and again under other sources.

2. P. Krishna Menon v. CIT (1959, SC)
   A spiritual teacher received regular gifts from a devotee. The Court held it taxable as “income from other sources” because the money was given in return for his spiritual teachings.
   ➤ Principle: Even voluntary gifts can be taxable if connected to services rendered.

3. Dr. K. George Thomas v. CIT (1985, SC)
   The Court held that if the income arises regularly from an activity, even if it’s religious or charitable, it becomes taxable under “Other Sources.”

---

Section 57 – Deductions from Income from Other Sources

Section 57 allows certain deductions for expenses that are wholly and exclusively incurred to earn the income under this head. These deductions are provided so that only net income is taxed, not the gross amount.

The main allowable deductions are:

1. Commission or remuneration paid to a banker or any other person for collecting interest or dividends.
2. Repair, insurance, or depreciation of machinery, plant, or furniture if such assets are let out on hire.
3. Other necessary expenses incurred entirely for earning such income.
4. For family pension, a standard deduction of one-third of such income or ₹15,000, whichever is less.

---

Important Case Law under Section 57

CIT v. Rajendra Prasad Moody (1978, SC)
The assessee borrowed money to buy shares but did not receive any dividend during the year. The Income-tax Department refused deduction of interest paid on loan.
The Supreme Court held that the deduction must be allowed because the purpose of borrowing was to earn dividend income.
➤ Principle: Deduction depends on the intention to earn income, not on whether income was actually received.

---

Section 58 – Disallowed Expenses (No Deductions Allowed)

Section 58 lists the expenses which cannot be claimed as deductions under this head. These are:

1. Personal expenses of the taxpayer.
2. Interest paid outside India without deduction of tax at source.
3. Expenses related to winnings from lotteries, gambling, horse races, or betting — no deductions are allowed here.
4. Wealth-tax or any illegal payment cannot be claimed as deduction.
5. Any fake or unverifiable expense is also not allowed.

---

Case Law under Section 58

Vijaybhai N. Chandrani v. CIT (2011, Gujarat High Court)
The Court held that when income comes from an illegal or undisclosed source, the assessee cannot claim any deduction of related expenses.
➤ Principle: No one can benefit from illegal or unlawful income by claiming deductions.

---

Conclusion

Sections 56 to 58 are very important because they ensure that every type of income, whether from legal business or other casual sources, is taxed fairly.
Section 56 charges all miscellaneous incomes to tax, Section 57 allows genuine deductions for earning that income, and Section 58 prevents misuse by disallowing personal or illegal expenses.

In short, these provisions make sure that no income escapes taxation and at the same time, only legitimate expenses are deducted. They maintain a balance between fairness and revenue protection in the Indian tax system.